What is the formula to win a Nobel prize?
Tharman: Curiosity, concern for society are some of the elements - but not glory seeking
By Shobana Kesava
MANY elements go into the formula that creates Nobel laureates, but seeking glory is not among them.
Instead, Education Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam and three laureates agree, the potent mix includes intense curiosity, wide interests, years of devotion and a concern for society.
Mr Tharman was opening the first Molecular Frontiers Forum yesterday at the Biopolis. The two-day event drew local and overseas award-winning scientists, researchers and students.
Mr Tharman, who is also Finance Minister, urged the youth present - from 14-year-olds to young adults - and their teachers, to follow their hearts and not be too concerned about seeking out the best route to success.
He cited numerous examples of laureates who had taken unusual paths. Several found the sciences only in adulthood.
Among them: Anthony J. Legget (Nobel prize in physics in 2003) first studied the classics at Oxford. Eric R. Kandell (medicine in 2000) majored in 19th and 20th century European history and literature at Harvard.
What it takes to be a winner
YEARS of scrutiny precede the granting of each $2.25 million Nobel Prize. Professor Bengt Norden (below) of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences in Sweden chairs a committee that picks each year's winner in chemistry. He lists the panel's criteria:
The discovery has to open the door to changing the way we think. It could be original, or the serendipity of what the scientist makes of a discovery.
... more
Not all started with sterling academic records. 'Some couldn't get into university,' he noted.
'Do what you want and what you love at every stage of your life and you usually do well as a result of it. Not because you want achievement or to show results but because you love it,' he said.
The three Nobel laureates in chemistry who spoke to the more than 300 students in the audience agreed that they had always been open to delving into wide interests - from baseball and fishing to carpentry. Read widely, they urged.
'You need to know what's going on in the world in order to make a difference to it,' said American professor Barry Sharpless, who won the prize in chemistry in 2001.
He said 20 per cent of his reading is unrelated to science.
Connections are important too. Japanese laureate Ryoji Noyori, who also won the award the same year, noted that he had met Prof Sharpless and Prof Richard Schrock in 1969 in Harvard.
An American, Prof Schrock won the prize in 2005.
'When you keep connecting with scientists in different labs, each may uncover an invisible spot in the other's work because everyone has a different approach,' said Prof Sharpless.
All agreed that one 'winning' factor perhaps stood out: society's needs.
'The only research I wanted to do was that which makes a difference in society,' said Prof Schrock, whose work is used in global pharmaceutical companies today.
The laureates are here as part of a drive by the Institute of Bioengineering and Nanotechnology and the Sweden-based Molecular Frontiers Foundation to promote appreciation of molecular science as well as entice youth to pursue scientific inquiry.
Singapore is trying to nurture a new generation of scientists and engineers to fuel the multibillion- dollar science and technology industry.
Yishun Junior College (JC) teacher Jacky Wong, who was at the forum, said molecular sciences like nanotechnology are not yet taught at the JC level, but the forum equips him to encourage students about the possibilities that lie ahead of them.
'Even if they don't end up choosing it as a career, science teaches lifelong skills, logic and systematic thinking,' he said.
Finding the sessions interesting, too, was university student Chin Sau Yin, 23, who was thrilled to meet the world-renowned scientists.
Said Miss Chin: 'They are real people who even took breaks from academia, which led them to ideas on what could help meet society's needs.'
skesava@sph.com.sg
Saturday, January 12, 2008
MM's keys to living long and successfully
Jan 12, 2008
MM's keys to living long and successfully
By Lee Siew Hua
PLUGGED IN: MM Lee says his days are high in stimuli and he is fully connected to the world. he says 'you must have a reason, you must have the stimuli, to keep going'. -- LIANHE ZAOBAO FILE PHOTO
View more photos
THE Minister Mentor has calculated his date with destiny.
His mother died of stroke at 74. His father was 94 when he died. Now that MM Lee Kuan Yew himself will turn 85 in September, he says: 'I've reached the halfway point.'
But he is living long and successfully - the theme of his dialogue at the first Silver Industry Conference - as his days are high in stimuli and he is fully connected to the world.
He would have shrunk away if he had retired, he said. 'Retirement means death,' he said, putting this point in the darkest light several times.
At a time when extending the retirement age is being debated, he thinks that those who expect to retire at 62 for a life of enjoyment are making the biggest mistake of their lives.
'If you want to see sunrise tomorrow or sunset, you must have a reason, you must have the stimuli, to keep going,' he said.
IND A REASON TO GO ON
'The biggest punishment a man can receive is total isolation in a dungeon, black and complete withdrawal of all stimuli, that's real torture. So when I read that people believe, Singaporeans say, 'Oh 62 I'm retiring.' I say to them, 'You really want to die quickly?'
'If you want to see sunrise tomorrow or sunset, you must have a reason, you must have the stimuli to keep going.'
MM LEE
WORK AT LOWER GEAR
'I do not believe we should have a retirement age. It is very difficult to switch from what is a world practice which we adopted, the British left us at 55, we pushed it up to 60 and pushed it up to 62.
I think a man should go on working or a woman should go on working for as long as we can but changing the nature or the intensity of the work as he ages.'
MM LEE
Brain drain worry hits close to home
THE worry over brain drain has hit close to home for Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew.
Yesterday, he related this story from within his family: 'I have a grandson who has just gone to MIT, he's doing economics... Fortunately for the father, he decided to apply for a Public Service Commission (PSC) scholarship, which means he is bonded to come back.
... more
His own father exemplified that. He swam every day and kept himself active. After retiring from the Shell company, he became a salesman, surprising people by selling watches at BP de Silva.
'But it kept him busy,' Mr Lee said. 'It kept him meeting friends.' His father had a routine, he added.
In a dialogue filled with family stories told with a light touch, he revealed how at each turning-point of life, he made choices to stay alive.
In his 30s, he was very fond of drinking and smoking.
Once, he met foreign correspondents, and an unflattering picture was printed. 'I had a big belly...a beer belly,' he told an amused audience of businessmen, policymakers and activists.
So he played more golf, but the belly stayed. 'There was only one way it could go down - consume less, burn out more.'
He quit smoking soon after he lost his voice and could not thank voters when he won a City Council election in 1957.
He would puff 10 cigarettes on stage before each campaign speech, watching people, sensing the mood.
'Three speeches a night, plenty of cigarettes, a lot of beer after that, and the voice was gone.'
His one-hour-plus dialogue showed a less-glimpsed side of the nation's founding father as he spoke freely of his frailty.
But, true to his forceful nature, he fought each brush with mortality.
At one turning point in the 1970s, his daughter, about to graduate as a doctor, found him breathing heavily on the Istana lawn.
He told her: 'I feel an effort to breathe in more oxygen.'
She said: 'Don't play golf. Run.'
He was not one bit keen on running, but loved golf. So in between golf shots, he started walking fast. Later, he ran.
After a few years, he told himself: 'Golf takes so long. The running takes 15 minutes. Let's cut down the golf and let's run.'
Another time, his doctor gave him a medical encyclopaedia, and he zoomed in on the ageing section to learn more.
'As you acquire more knowledge, you then craft a programme for yourself to maximise what you have,' he said.
In his case, he said, he has 'led a very active life, connected with the world'.
And all that he has accumulated, he interprets it for Singapore, he said. Including his ideas about ageing vitally.
siewhua@sph.com.sg
MM's keys to living long and successfully
By Lee Siew Hua
PLUGGED IN: MM Lee says his days are high in stimuli and he is fully connected to the world. he says 'you must have a reason, you must have the stimuli, to keep going'. -- LIANHE ZAOBAO FILE PHOTO
View more photos
THE Minister Mentor has calculated his date with destiny.
His mother died of stroke at 74. His father was 94 when he died. Now that MM Lee Kuan Yew himself will turn 85 in September, he says: 'I've reached the halfway point.'
But he is living long and successfully - the theme of his dialogue at the first Silver Industry Conference - as his days are high in stimuli and he is fully connected to the world.
He would have shrunk away if he had retired, he said. 'Retirement means death,' he said, putting this point in the darkest light several times.
At a time when extending the retirement age is being debated, he thinks that those who expect to retire at 62 for a life of enjoyment are making the biggest mistake of their lives.
'If you want to see sunrise tomorrow or sunset, you must have a reason, you must have the stimuli, to keep going,' he said.
IND A REASON TO GO ON
'The biggest punishment a man can receive is total isolation in a dungeon, black and complete withdrawal of all stimuli, that's real torture. So when I read that people believe, Singaporeans say, 'Oh 62 I'm retiring.' I say to them, 'You really want to die quickly?'
'If you want to see sunrise tomorrow or sunset, you must have a reason, you must have the stimuli to keep going.'
MM LEE
WORK AT LOWER GEAR
'I do not believe we should have a retirement age. It is very difficult to switch from what is a world practice which we adopted, the British left us at 55, we pushed it up to 60 and pushed it up to 62.
I think a man should go on working or a woman should go on working for as long as we can but changing the nature or the intensity of the work as he ages.'
MM LEE
Brain drain worry hits close to home
THE worry over brain drain has hit close to home for Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew.
Yesterday, he related this story from within his family: 'I have a grandson who has just gone to MIT, he's doing economics... Fortunately for the father, he decided to apply for a Public Service Commission (PSC) scholarship, which means he is bonded to come back.
... more
His own father exemplified that. He swam every day and kept himself active. After retiring from the Shell company, he became a salesman, surprising people by selling watches at BP de Silva.
'But it kept him busy,' Mr Lee said. 'It kept him meeting friends.' His father had a routine, he added.
In a dialogue filled with family stories told with a light touch, he revealed how at each turning-point of life, he made choices to stay alive.
In his 30s, he was very fond of drinking and smoking.
Once, he met foreign correspondents, and an unflattering picture was printed. 'I had a big belly...a beer belly,' he told an amused audience of businessmen, policymakers and activists.
So he played more golf, but the belly stayed. 'There was only one way it could go down - consume less, burn out more.'
He quit smoking soon after he lost his voice and could not thank voters when he won a City Council election in 1957.
He would puff 10 cigarettes on stage before each campaign speech, watching people, sensing the mood.
'Three speeches a night, plenty of cigarettes, a lot of beer after that, and the voice was gone.'
His one-hour-plus dialogue showed a less-glimpsed side of the nation's founding father as he spoke freely of his frailty.
But, true to his forceful nature, he fought each brush with mortality.
At one turning point in the 1970s, his daughter, about to graduate as a doctor, found him breathing heavily on the Istana lawn.
He told her: 'I feel an effort to breathe in more oxygen.'
She said: 'Don't play golf. Run.'
He was not one bit keen on running, but loved golf. So in between golf shots, he started walking fast. Later, he ran.
After a few years, he told himself: 'Golf takes so long. The running takes 15 minutes. Let's cut down the golf and let's run.'
Another time, his doctor gave him a medical encyclopaedia, and he zoomed in on the ageing section to learn more.
'As you acquire more knowledge, you then craft a programme for yourself to maximise what you have,' he said.
In his case, he said, he has 'led a very active life, connected with the world'.
And all that he has accumulated, he interprets it for Singapore, he said. Including his ideas about ageing vitally.
siewhua@sph.com.sg
Friday, January 11, 2008

Obituary: Sir Edmund Hillary
Sir Edmund Hillary, who has died at the age of 88, made it to the summit of Everest in 1953, and became the first man on the planet to reach its highest point.
As a boy in New Zealand, Edmund Hillary's fragile appearance belied his ground-breaking potential.
At school, he was in a gym group for those lacking co-ordination and admitted to feeling a "deep sense of inferiority".
But the 40-mile journey to school in Auckland each day gave young Edmund many hours to pore over adventure stories and travel ever further in his mind.
Unrecorded achievement
Although Sir Edmund briefly worked as a beekeeper after he left school, he had found his true vocation at the age of 16 while on a school trip to Mount Ruapehu, 320km (200 miles) south of Auckland.
He had seen snow for the first time as well as learning to climb.
After spending two years as a navigator in the New Zealand's air force, he joined a local Alpine Club to take on all the national peaks.
Unsatisfied by these local triumphs, he also travelled to the Himalayas and started wrestling to improve his strength.
This was all with the idea of taking on the ultimate challenge, becoming the first man to climb Everest.
By the time Sir Edmund attempted his ascent, seven previous expeditions to the top of the world's highest mountain had failed.
Sir Edmund recalled: "We didn't know if it was humanly possible to reach the top."
Despite this general trepidation, the determined New Zealander joined a trip led by British climber, Sir John Hunt.
After a gruelling climb up the southern face, battling the effects of high altitude and bad weather, Sir Edmund and Tenzing Norgay managed to reach the peak at 1130 local time on 29 May.
'All this - and Everest too!'
When they finally reached the top Sir Edmund, who lost four stone on the expedition, reported his first sensation as one of relief.
He took the famous photo of his Sherpa companion posing with his ice-axe, but refused Tenzing's offer to take one of him, so his ascent went unrecorded.
On the morning of Queen Elizabeth's coronation in May 1953, her subjects were told that Sir Edmund had made it to the summit.
As he was a New Zealander and therefore a citizen of the Commonwealth, British subjects celebrated his achievement as their own.
On the day the Queen was crowned, one newspaper headline crowed "All this - and Everest too!"
Sir Edmund was knighted for his efforts, and Tenzing given a medal.
The pair initially reported the ascent as one made in unison. Only after the Sherpa's death in 1986, did Sir Edmund reveal that he had been about 10 feet ahead at the final ridge.
Personal tragedy
Sir Edmund was apparently so shy that he even proposed to his wife with a message via her mother.
In the years that followed his famous ascent, he shunned the celebrity that had become his overnight.
Sir Edmund declined the Queen's invitation on the 50th anniversary
On the 50th anniversary of his achievement, he even turned down an invitation from the Queen, so that he could instead travel to Kathmandu to be with lifelong Sherpa friends.
He was made an honorary Nepalese citizen in 2003.
Sir Edmund was far happier exploring.
During the next two decades, he led expeditions to the South Pole, searched for the fabled Yeti, and completed six Himalayan ascents.
And he became increasingly concerned by the plight of the Sherpa people he had met on his expeditions.
He spent two years as New Zealand's High Commissioner to India, and founded the Himalayan Trust in 1964, which helped establish clinics, hospitals and nearly 30 schools.
It also supported the construction of two airstrips, bringing in more tourists than Sir Edmund liked.
He continued this work after personal tragedy in 1975, when his wife and daughter died in a plane crash on their way to meet him at a construction site.
Although the explorer was inconsolable for a long time, he found solace in the Nepal landscape and its people.
'Life's a bit like mountaineering...'
He was a vociferous opponent of what he considered the commercialisation of the mountain, rich tourists paying their way to the ultimate altitude thrill, and often leaving rubbish behind them.
Sir Edmund enjoyed the friendship of Norgay and the Sherpa people
Seemingly forgetting his own determination to conquer the high ridges, Sir Edmund urged these later climbers to "leave the mountains in peace".
Although he will always be remembered for reaching the world's highest plateau, for the explorer himself, his greatest satisfaction came with the Nepalese people he befriended.
He said: "My most worthwhile things have been the building of schools and clinics. That has given me more satisfaction than a footprint on a mountain."
Sir Edmund Hillary remained philosophical about living with such an early achievement. He explained: "I've had a full and rewarding life. Life's a bit like mountaineering - never look down."


'My Himalayan climb with Hillary'
Brian Wilkins said Sir Edmund was an "utterly sensible person"
Mountaineer Brian Wilkins climbed with Sir Edmund Hillary, who has died at the age of 88, in the Himalayas in 1954. He told his daughter, BBC News's Lucy Wilkins, Hillary would be remembered for his "utter common sense" and determination.
Dr Wilkins was a young mountaineer chosen as one of 10 climbers in the New Zealand Alpine Club expedition to attempt peaks to the east of Everest.
Charles Evans, who had failed to reach the world's highest summit in Hillary's expedition, was also to climb with Dr Wilkins.
Even though Sir Edmund had won world-wide acclaim and was feted everywhere he went after the conquest of Everest with Sherpa Tenzing Norgay the year before, he did not forget his prior commitments.
He had a tremendous determination. Even though he wasn't eating much, he showed he could go on for hours
"Despite all the demands on his time after Everest, such as writing a book about his life, he kept his promise. In all we climbed about 20 peaks over 20,000 ft," Dr Wilkins told the BBC News website from his home in Wellington, New Zealand.
But it was not all easy going for a man who had achieved a world first.
"The thing that I most remember about Ed, despite the fact that he wasn't at all well and he wasn't eating much, he was still able to go very well.
"He had a tremendous determination. Even though he wasn't eating much, he showed he could go on for hours," Dr Wilkins said.
Teamwork
Sir Edmund's lack of appetite was never fully explained, and Dr Wilkins said he had serious bouts of sickness in subsequent climbs. Once during the NZ Alpine Club climb, he collapsed and had to be carried down to a lower altitude.
But having a celebrity in their midst did not affect the NZ Alpine Club climbers.
Sir Edmund enjoyed being among fellow New Zealanders
"We were certainly conscious of who he was - a world-famous mountaineer. But once you're out there in the mountains you're all sleeping in the same tent, you're all part of the same endeavour.
"He was an utterly sensible person. He enjoyed spending time amongst New Zealanders because for him it was being back in the environment that he had worked his way up through."
For Dr Wilkins, a retired scientist, who is still an active climber at the age of 82, his down-to-earth qualities will be remembered as key to one of New Zealand's most famous sons.
"His face appears on one of our banknotes, he was given the highest honours in New Zealand, he was the high commissioner to India, but I think the thing that New Zealanders admired in him most was his utter common sense."
And the Sherpa people around the Everest region will miss him greatly too, Dr Wilkins said, as Sir Edmund set up a trust for building schools, hospitals and bridges which had become "his life's work".



Tributes for Everest 'colossus'
Sir Edmund Hillary was made an honorary Nepalese citizen
Everest hero
Tributes have been paid to Sir Edmund Hillary, the first man to reach the top of the world's highest peak, Mount Everest, after he died aged 88.
New Zealand PM Helen Clark said a state funeral would be held for Sir Edmund, while Queen Elizabeth II said she was "very saddened" by his death.
Nepali Sherpas lit lamps and offered special Buddhist prayers in monasteries for his reincarnation.
Sir Edmund conquered the peak with Tenzing Norgay on 29 May 1953.
The first living New Zealander to appear on a banknote, his health had reportedly been failing since April, when he suffered a fall during a visit to Nepal.
'Legendary'
Flags at the New Zealand parliament in Wellington and at the Scott Base in Antarctica were at half mast as a mark of respect to the climber, who died of a heart attack at Auckland Hospital at 0900 local time Friday (2000 GMT Thursday).
All New Zealanders will deeply mourn his passing
New Zealand's prime minister described him as a "colossus".
"The legendary mountaineer, adventurer, and philanthropist is the best-known New Zealander ever to have lived," Ms Clark said in a statement.
"But most of all he was a quintessential Kiwi.
"He was ours - from his craggy appearance to laconic style, to his directness and honesty. All New Zealanders will deeply mourn his passing."
'Knocked off'
Buckingham Palace in London said the Queen was sending a personal message of sympathy to Sir Edmund's widow and family.
The climber was 33 years old when he and Tenzing Norgay become the first men to climb the 8,850m (29,035ft) peak, just days before the monarch's coronation.
Before reaching base camp, ascent team walked 175 miles (282km) from Kathmandu and spent three weeks acclimatising
On May 26 initial attempt came within 300ft (91m) of summit, with final bid two days later
Five man team helped Hillary and Norgay to precarious point high up mountain where pair spent night in tent
Next morning they set out at 0630, reaching summit 1130
Returning to Everest's South Col camp, he famously greeted another member of the British expedition group with the words: "Well, George, we've knocked the bastard off."
Sir Edmund was knighted that year by the Queen for his achievement, and 42 years later was awarded her highest award for chivalry - the Order of the Garter.
His climbing partner died in 1986 but his son, Jamling Tenzing Norgay, said Sir Edmund was "a great explorer".
"The most important of all is that he was humble man, a simple man," he added.
The Sherpa community in Nepal said they were planning a memorial to the man they considered a second father.
"I lit butter lamps and offered prayers for his reincarnation as a human being," said Ang Rita Sherpa, 60.
After scaling Everest, Sir Edmund led a number of expeditions to the South Pole and devoted his life to helping the ethnic Sherpas of Nepal's Khumbu region.
Summit race
His Himalayan Trust has helped build hospitals, clinics, bridges, airstrips and nearly 30 schools. He was made an honorary Nepalese citizen in 2003.
To my great delight I realised we were on top of Mount Everest and that the whole world spread out below us
Sir Edmund: Your tributes
Born in Auckland on 19 July 1919, Sir Edmund began climbing mountains in his native country as a teenager and soon earned renown as an ice climber.
By the time he attempted his ascent of Everest in 1953 as part of an expedition led by the British climber, Sir John Hunt, seven previous expeditions to the top of the mountain had failed.
After a gruelling climb up the southern face, battling the effects of high altitude and bad weather, Sir Edmund and Tenzing Norgay managed to reach the peak at 1130 local time on 29 May.
"I continued hacking steps along the ridge and then up a few more to the right... to my great delight I realised we were on top of Mount Everest and that the whole world spread out below us," Sir Edmund said.
The two men only stayed on the summit for 15 minutes because they were low on oxygen.
Thursday, January 10, 2008
A gracious Singapore? Not in my lifetime: MM - 9 Jan 2008
ISEAS 40TH ANNIVERSARY
A gracious Singapore? Not in my lifetime: MM
He says cultivating social graces will take longer compared to environmental consciousness
By Li Xueying
IT TAKES TIME: Mr Lee said he hoped a gracious society 'will come with cultivated living over a long period of time'. -- ST PHOTO: TERENCE TAN
ENVIRONMENTAL consciousness among Singaporeans will come about very quickly when they realise how they will be in trouble when changes in the climate take place.
But attaining a gracious society will take more time, said Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew on Monday at a dialogue marking the 40th anniversary of the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies (Iseas).
In fact, he believes it will not happen in his lifetime.
'I will not see it, maybe you will live long enough to see it; I wish you well,' he told 48-year-old economics academic Euston Quah to laughter from the audience of diplomats, academics and government leaders.
Dr Quah had asked a question about Singapore's progress in terms of social graces and environmental consciousness just as the country succeeds economically.
The issue he raised was among a host of subjects brought up by the audience, from the situation in Myanmar to the rise of China and India.
Muslim radicals in S-E Asia will not prevail
MINISTER Mentor Lee Kuan Yew believes that Islamic terrorists in South-east Asia cannot win the war against their governments.
He is optimistic that 'the early burst of enthusiasm that they can change the world' may fade away.
Speaking in response to a question on whether South-east Asian governments are losing the fight against terrorism, Mr Lee said on Monday: 'I'm not sure that's correct. I don't think they are losing so much as they are not beating it down as well as they can. The problem is they are not winning the hearts and minds of the people.'
... more
In his reply, Mr Lee said a gracious society will not happen so fast. 'I think it will take more time to develop and mature culturally as a people.'
Even the British, he said, were 'sitting at a very high level over an empire for nearly 150 years before they developed their culture and then being invaded by football hooligans and foreigners who are now joining them and coarsening their society'.
'So it's very difficult to get a rough society onto a cultivated plane and it's very easy to bring it down,' he concluded.
Environmental consciousness, on the other hand, will come very quickly 'when something happens and they say, you do that, your whole environment changes and you are in trouble'.
On the other hand, the idea of a gracious society - 'where people are considerate to one another, where you don't make more noise to upset your neighbour than you need to, where you tell the other motorist, please have the right of way' - was 'harder to come by', said Mr Lee.
'It will take time, but I hope it will come with cultivated living over a long period of time.'
Mr Lee recalled how, 45 years ago, Singaporeans wanted to take their chickens with them when they were resettled from kampungs into high-rise flats.
'So it took some time to get them adjusted. A more cultivated way of life takes a very long time,' he said.
xueying@sph.com.sg
A gracious Singapore? Not in my lifetime: MM
He says cultivating social graces will take longer compared to environmental consciousness
By Li Xueying
IT TAKES TIME: Mr Lee said he hoped a gracious society 'will come with cultivated living over a long period of time'. -- ST PHOTO: TERENCE TAN
ENVIRONMENTAL consciousness among Singaporeans will come about very quickly when they realise how they will be in trouble when changes in the climate take place.
But attaining a gracious society will take more time, said Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew on Monday at a dialogue marking the 40th anniversary of the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies (Iseas).
In fact, he believes it will not happen in his lifetime.
'I will not see it, maybe you will live long enough to see it; I wish you well,' he told 48-year-old economics academic Euston Quah to laughter from the audience of diplomats, academics and government leaders.
Dr Quah had asked a question about Singapore's progress in terms of social graces and environmental consciousness just as the country succeeds economically.
The issue he raised was among a host of subjects brought up by the audience, from the situation in Myanmar to the rise of China and India.
Muslim radicals in S-E Asia will not prevail
MINISTER Mentor Lee Kuan Yew believes that Islamic terrorists in South-east Asia cannot win the war against their governments.
He is optimistic that 'the early burst of enthusiasm that they can change the world' may fade away.
Speaking in response to a question on whether South-east Asian governments are losing the fight against terrorism, Mr Lee said on Monday: 'I'm not sure that's correct. I don't think they are losing so much as they are not beating it down as well as they can. The problem is they are not winning the hearts and minds of the people.'
... more
In his reply, Mr Lee said a gracious society will not happen so fast. 'I think it will take more time to develop and mature culturally as a people.'
Even the British, he said, were 'sitting at a very high level over an empire for nearly 150 years before they developed their culture and then being invaded by football hooligans and foreigners who are now joining them and coarsening their society'.
'So it's very difficult to get a rough society onto a cultivated plane and it's very easy to bring it down,' he concluded.
Environmental consciousness, on the other hand, will come very quickly 'when something happens and they say, you do that, your whole environment changes and you are in trouble'.
On the other hand, the idea of a gracious society - 'where people are considerate to one another, where you don't make more noise to upset your neighbour than you need to, where you tell the other motorist, please have the right of way' - was 'harder to come by', said Mr Lee.
'It will take time, but I hope it will come with cultivated living over a long period of time.'
Mr Lee recalled how, 45 years ago, Singaporeans wanted to take their chickens with them when they were resettled from kampungs into high-rise flats.
'So it took some time to get them adjusted. A more cultivated way of life takes a very long time,' he said.
xueying@sph.com.sg
A gracious Singapore? Not in my lifetime: MM - 9 Jan 2008
ISEAS 40TH ANNIVERSARY
A gracious Singapore? Not in my lifetime: MM
He says cultivating social graces will take longer compared to environmental consciousness
By Li Xueying
IT TAKES TIME: Mr Lee said he hoped a gracious society 'will come with cultivated living over a long period of time'. -- ST PHOTO: TERENCE TAN
ENVIRONMENTAL consciousness among Singaporeans will come about very quickly when they realise how they will be in trouble when changes in the climate take place.
But attaining a gracious society will take more time, said Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew on Monday at a dialogue marking the 40th anniversary of the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies (Iseas).
In fact, he believes it will not happen in his lifetime.
'I will not see it, maybe you will live long enough to see it; I wish you well,' he told 48-year-old economics academic Euston Quah to laughter from the audience of diplomats, academics and government leaders.
Dr Quah had asked a question about Singapore's progress in terms of social graces and environmental consciousness just as the country succeeds economically.
The issue he raised was among a host of subjects brought up by the audience, from the situation in Myanmar to the rise of China and India.
Muslim radicals in S-E Asia will not prevail
MINISTER Mentor Lee Kuan Yew believes that Islamic terrorists in South-east Asia cannot win the war against their governments.
He is optimistic that 'the early burst of enthusiasm that they can change the world' may fade away.
Speaking in response to a question on whether South-east Asian governments are losing the fight against terrorism, Mr Lee said on Monday: 'I'm not sure that's correct. I don't think they are losing so much as they are not beating it down as well as they can. The problem is they are not winning the hearts and minds of the people.'
... more
In his reply, Mr Lee said a gracious society will not happen so fast. 'I think it will take more time to develop and mature culturally as a people.'
Even the British, he said, were 'sitting at a very high level over an empire for nearly 150 years before they developed their culture and then being invaded by football hooligans and foreigners who are now joining them and coarsening their society'.
'So it's very difficult to get a rough society onto a cultivated plane and it's very easy to bring it down,' he concluded.
Environmental consciousness, on the other hand, will come very quickly 'when something happens and they say, you do that, your whole environment changes and you are in trouble'.
On the other hand, the idea of a gracious society - 'where people are considerate to one another, where you don't make more noise to upset your neighbour than you need to, where you tell the other motorist, please have the right of way' - was 'harder to come by', said Mr Lee.
'It will take time, but I hope it will come with cultivated living over a long period of time.'
Mr Lee recalled how, 45 years ago, Singaporeans wanted to take their chickens with them when they were resettled from kampungs into high-rise flats.
'So it took some time to get them adjusted. A more cultivated way of life takes a very long time,' he said.
xueying@sph.com.sg
A gracious Singapore? Not in my lifetime: MM
He says cultivating social graces will take longer compared to environmental consciousness
By Li Xueying
IT TAKES TIME: Mr Lee said he hoped a gracious society 'will come with cultivated living over a long period of time'. -- ST PHOTO: TERENCE TAN
ENVIRONMENTAL consciousness among Singaporeans will come about very quickly when they realise how they will be in trouble when changes in the climate take place.
But attaining a gracious society will take more time, said Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew on Monday at a dialogue marking the 40th anniversary of the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies (Iseas).
In fact, he believes it will not happen in his lifetime.
'I will not see it, maybe you will live long enough to see it; I wish you well,' he told 48-year-old economics academic Euston Quah to laughter from the audience of diplomats, academics and government leaders.
Dr Quah had asked a question about Singapore's progress in terms of social graces and environmental consciousness just as the country succeeds economically.
The issue he raised was among a host of subjects brought up by the audience, from the situation in Myanmar to the rise of China and India.
Muslim radicals in S-E Asia will not prevail
MINISTER Mentor Lee Kuan Yew believes that Islamic terrorists in South-east Asia cannot win the war against their governments.
He is optimistic that 'the early burst of enthusiasm that they can change the world' may fade away.
Speaking in response to a question on whether South-east Asian governments are losing the fight against terrorism, Mr Lee said on Monday: 'I'm not sure that's correct. I don't think they are losing so much as they are not beating it down as well as they can. The problem is they are not winning the hearts and minds of the people.'
... more
In his reply, Mr Lee said a gracious society will not happen so fast. 'I think it will take more time to develop and mature culturally as a people.'
Even the British, he said, were 'sitting at a very high level over an empire for nearly 150 years before they developed their culture and then being invaded by football hooligans and foreigners who are now joining them and coarsening their society'.
'So it's very difficult to get a rough society onto a cultivated plane and it's very easy to bring it down,' he concluded.
Environmental consciousness, on the other hand, will come very quickly 'when something happens and they say, you do that, your whole environment changes and you are in trouble'.
On the other hand, the idea of a gracious society - 'where people are considerate to one another, where you don't make more noise to upset your neighbour than you need to, where you tell the other motorist, please have the right of way' - was 'harder to come by', said Mr Lee.
'It will take time, but I hope it will come with cultivated living over a long period of time.'
Mr Lee recalled how, 45 years ago, Singaporeans wanted to take their chickens with them when they were resettled from kampungs into high-rise flats.
'So it took some time to get them adjusted. A more cultivated way of life takes a very long time,' he said.
xueying@sph.com.sg
Jan 5, 2008 - Year of the UN reef
Jan 5, 2008
2008: The International Year of the...
IN DANGER: Indonesia's coral reefs are under threat from coral mining and illegal fishing. -- PHOTO: AFP
POTATO
WHO DECLARED IT: The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation
WHY: It will be an important staple in times of food scarcity. It occupies less land than other cereal crops for the amount of nutrition provided. It also draws the attention of the world to food crops and agriculture.
WEBLINK: www.potato2008.org
PLANET EARTH
WHO DECLARED IT: The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (Unesco) and the International Union of Geological Sciences.
WHY: Attention to earth sciences will make the world a safer place to live. Scientists estimate that hundreds of thousands of lives could have been saved during the Boxing Day tsunami in 2004, with properly trained geologists, equipment and networking among meteorological stations around the globe.
WEBLINK: www.yearofplanetearth.org
CORAL REEF
WHO DECLARED IT: The International Coral Reef Initiative (ICRI), a 13-year partnershipamong world bodies, governments and non-government organisations.
WHY: To raise awareness about reefs and motivate action to reverse damage done. If trends continue, this decline is likely to lead to the loss of most of the world's reef resources in the next century.
WEBLINK: www.iyor.org
FROG
WHO DECLARED IT: Amphibian Ark
WHY: A third of all amphibians are threatened. The campaign draws attention to frogs, which are a key indicator of environmental health.
WEBLINK: www.amphibianark.org
2008: The International Year of the...
IN DANGER: Indonesia's coral reefs are under threat from coral mining and illegal fishing. -- PHOTO: AFP
POTATO
WHO DECLARED IT: The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation
WHY: It will be an important staple in times of food scarcity. It occupies less land than other cereal crops for the amount of nutrition provided. It also draws the attention of the world to food crops and agriculture.
WEBLINK: www.potato2008.org
PLANET EARTH
WHO DECLARED IT: The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (Unesco) and the International Union of Geological Sciences.
WHY: Attention to earth sciences will make the world a safer place to live. Scientists estimate that hundreds of thousands of lives could have been saved during the Boxing Day tsunami in 2004, with properly trained geologists, equipment and networking among meteorological stations around the globe.
WEBLINK: www.yearofplanetearth.org
CORAL REEF
WHO DECLARED IT: The International Coral Reef Initiative (ICRI), a 13-year partnershipamong world bodies, governments and non-government organisations.
WHY: To raise awareness about reefs and motivate action to reverse damage done. If trends continue, this decline is likely to lead to the loss of most of the world's reef resources in the next century.
WEBLINK: www.iyor.org
FROG
WHO DECLARED IT: Amphibian Ark
WHY: A third of all amphibians are threatened. The campaign draws attention to frogs, which are a key indicator of environmental health.
WEBLINK: www.amphibianark.org
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)